Playing the blame game

Posted: April 27, 2011 in business, investor
Tags: , , , , ,

Today I finally read through the Nyberg Report on the cause of the banking crisis in Ireland. The report was released recently but doesn’t really contain anything that someone with a brain and a heartbeat didn’t already know. Hence I will not rehash the content as there are legions in Ireland already doing so.

Playing the blame game seems to be de riguer at the moment, we’re all frantically pointing the finger in a desperate attempt to assign blame to some faceless party for the mess we are in. It’s the bankers, the government, the developers, the regulator, the media, foreign banks, the EU, the ECB, Lehman Brothers who are at fault. However what you rarely will hear is that we the people living in Ireland (or at least the majority) are just as much at fault. Yes we had banks with unhealthy lending practices and we had a government who not only failed to prevent a crisis but who actually encouraged unsound financial practices but we also had people buying 1, 2, 3, 4 and more houses at inflated prices, we had people taking out 2nd & 3rd mortgages on the same property, we had the frenzy of buying a new car every time the year changed. We had people from lower & middle-income classes taking multiple foreign holidays. We had designer kitchens, designer luggage, designer clothing and designer weddings. We even had designer pets and designer pet accessories. Most of us basically went mad.

Allthis was paid for with borrowed money. Not our own borrowed money but money that our banks borrowed abroad without actually applying logic to the feasibility of ever being able to repay it. And when the economic shit hit the financial fan we were way up the proverbial creek with not a paddle in sight.

However while reading the Nyberg report there was a paragraph on page 116 that really put the frighteners up me;

The result, as shown by the crisis itself, was that no effective brake on risk-taking existed for years.
It does not appear wholly unfair to propose that this is what may happen also in the future if
and when another new financial or banking paradigm appears. Many of the very reforms that
recently have been undertaken, at short notice, to shore up the functioning of the present
financial system could turn out, once again, to be ineffective.

And there you go. In spite of all the talking, report, and the endless stream of Primetime, Frontline, Vincent Browne broadcasts we have learned nothing….

Advertisements
Comments
  1. liam says:

    Hi Evert

    I agree totally the finger-wagging is helpful to no-one. My beef with it though is that while we blather on about who is at fault, we’re not focused on what to do about the mess! And if our reaction to a crisis is to point fingers of blame rather than deal with the situation, then yes there is certainly no incentive to avoid future crises, since the consequences of bad decisions in our minds are always somebody else’s fault.

    Just as an aside:

    “However what you rarely will hear is that we the people living in Ireland (or at least the majority) are just as much at fault.”

    Thats possibly true in very broad terms but I don’t think somehow its quite as simple as that. However, isn’t this the blame game in different clothes? In any case, it turns out that certainly the overwhelming majority of ordinary citizens are the only ones being punished.

  2. business says:

    Proponents are asking Californians to borrow 6 billion including interest in a state thats already in financial ruinwhere our senior citizens are having services cut roads are not being repaired schools are closing childrens health care needs of today are not being metand were supposed to go deeper into debt for this speculative biotechnological research..Who is poised to benefit the most from this referendum?.Biotech corporations and research centers and universities that will be paid with borrowed money to conduct research into human cloning and embryonic stem cells. I question whether the public will actually understand the terms of this complicated measure or that it seeks a constitutional right to conduct research into human cloning or somatic cell nuclear transfer SCNT as it is known scientifically.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s